I definitely like the first half of the book better than the second half, but that said, this is one of my favorite books. I don't usually buy books, but this is one I own, because I know I'll want to re-read it many times.

I've read this book a couple of times, and while it starts out great, it always disappoints in the end. It's a prequel of sorts to "The Blue Sword" and has none of that book's great storytelling. Aerin works hard to find a place in her father's court, but after she develops her initial skills, magical accidents and coincidences save the day. She's a Mary Sue character who is progressed through the story by outside forces. This would have been a much better story if it had not tried so hard to match the world of "The Blue Sword", but it is still worth a read if you are a McKinley fan.

A rich bold story that gets to the core of "The Hero's" feelings.

Wonderful, slightly challenging read. The description is a bit off, but I'll let it go. Aerin is one of my favorite characters ever, and I'm sure she'll be yours too, she's charming, realistic, and fearless. Great book!

The description of this book, first of all, isn't very accurate; first of all, Luthe isn't a wizard. Now, for the book itself ... This is my favourite of all Robin McKinley's books -- the characters are the most alive of any characters she has portrayed, and the story is riveting. I have read it SO many times that I know it by heart. Aerin now lives in my mind as one of my heroes. The word I thought summed the book up for me was: refreshing. I felt awakened and alive and refreshed once I had finished, and immediately began reading it again.

Anyone looking for a book with a strong, female protagonist, dragons, and a hint of romance has found the perfect book! It was one of my first books I read in the fantasy genre as a child and it still remains one of my favorite books. You will not be disappointed!